X-Men Top 10 - Just For Fun! RESULTS!!!!!

Polaris (70s Shi'Ar costume)
Husk
Penance (Gen X look)
Hepzibah
Raza
Feral
Marina
Talismen (classic costume)
Rachel Summers Phoenix (red spiky hound outfit)
Magik (classic yellow and black New Mutants costume)

bad guys

Exodus
Proteus (90s card look)
Shadow King (fully transformed look)
Thornn 2
Masque
Mastermind (classic look)
Deathbird
Mesmero
Unus
Vanisher (classic green costume)

Top 10 X-Men Antagonists

Deathbird

Cameron Hodge

Mastermind - duster

Exodus

Cassandra Nova

Vanisher

Unus the Untouchable

Mesmero

Hussar

Manta

I was tempted to add Imperial Guard members, but thought that it'd be better if they had their own top ten. 😀 Easier to choose, then. 😉

Good:

AOA Nightcrawler

AOA Gambit

AOA Quicksilver

AOA Storm

AOA Banshee

AOA Dazzler

AOA Angel

AOA Exodus

AOA Bishop

Feral / Bandana Wolverine

Bad:

AOA Infinite Soldier Army Builder

AOA Sinister

AOA Havok

AOA Abyss

AOA Mikhail

AOA Holocaust

Phalanx / Harvest

90s Captive Emma Frost

Phalanx Cameron Hodge

90s Captive Sabretooth

1) Human Beast, red and blue graduation costume

2) Banshee in classic green and yellow

3) Psylocke (pink puffy costume)

4) Beast (Pérez Avengers)

5) Beast (human, X-Factor red and blue)

6) Angel (X-Factor red and white)

7) Cyclops (X-Factor blue and yellow)

8) Jean Grey (X-Factor green and yellow)

9) Iceman (depowered, X-Factor blue and white)

10) ANY of the Imperial Guard members

Villains:

1) Deathbird

2) Mimic (handbook/classic first appearance)

3) Unus the Untouchable

4) Mesmero (classic green handbook costume)

5-10) ANY Imperial Guard members here

Heroes:

1. Cockrum Cyclops

2. Late 60's Marvel Girl

3. Late 60's human Beast (red/blue)

4. Green Banshee

5. Raza

6. Hepzibah

7. Warstar

8. Titan

9. Smasher

10. Electron

Villains:

1. Scalphunter

2. Blockbuster

3. Mesmero

4. Mimic

5. Arclight

6. Harpoon

7. Erik the Red

8. Deathbird

9. Riptide

10. Unus

Ok, this is definitely going to be my favorite list! I could easily do a Top 100 of previously unmade X-Men. Once we hit the Krakoa Age, good vs bad became even more fluid, so I think that I'm just going to do a full Top 20 regardless of good/bad. There will be zero previously made characters on my list. I consider anyone who has ever had a Legends figure done in this scale by either company to be ineligible for any of my lists. While I do still buy a lot of re'do's/re'makes (like this year's deluxe Phoenix), I would never ask for them when there are so many great characters that have NEVER been done yet.

1) Rockslide

2. Pixie

3. Anole

4. Armor

5. Magma

6. Husk

7. Cypher

8. Sage

9. Krakoa

9. Hellion

10. Valerie Cooper

11. Dust

12. Surge

13. Mercury

14. Dr Nemesis

15. Glob Herman

16. Marrow

17. Elixir

18. Frenzy

19. Exodus

20. Temper (Oya)

I could have easily gone on and on with this one, but I'll stick to the rules and cap it at 20 total.

I have to admit after X-Men, Avengers, Spider-Man and Fantastic Four, I don't think that I could come up with a Top 10 for any other group, though.

Heroes

Trying to go with ones that haven't been made or that I haven't made:

Skin

Synch

Husk/Gen X Jubes

Marrow

Zero Tolerance Cannonball

De-powered Bobby

Penance

97 Civilian Sunspot 🙂

Shard

Rachel

X-tagonists:

Zero Tolerance Bastion (proper comic human head)

Deathbird

Hepzibah

Raza

Penance

Sebastian Shaw shirtless

TBD on the rest

I left off Green/Yellow Uniform Banshee and Husk because of the chance they are already in the pipeline.

One representative each from Alpha Flight, Generation X, Acolytes, X-Force, Morlocks, New X-Men, New Mutants, Excalibur, Shi'ar Empire, and X-Men.

X-time!

there’s a couple of redos on this list with additional differences, but I’d take plenty of straight up redos with pinless (gambit) or better artic (rogue/psylocke) as well. Also - a spoiler for a Deadpool 3 cameo in the second image.

Am taking the leak lists at their word so Cortez isn’t on here, who otherwise would be.

And I’m as interested in the toy being good as the character, so for the women I’d not be interested in em without the added torso artic, or men or women with pinned limbs.

Antagonists

Exodus - I’d opt for soft goods cape ideally.

omega - am thinking a ‘capcom’ cable style approach to the straps, for better articulation.

Sinister is specifically the long haired krakoan look.

Hazard

Weapon omega

Greycrow

Original toon sabertooth

Deathbird

Frenzy

Feilong

Protagonist camp!

New x men Jean

New x men cyke - both gotta be ribbed!

Jean x men red costume in hoxpox green and gold

97 cable blue/gold suit

X men red storm

X men evolution wolverine

Ablation suit wolvie

Deadpool gambit

The wolverine end credit costume

Astonishing colossus

Love these threads, thanks for putting em together @beamish !

Brace yourselves for my basic ass top 10ers. Just the baddies for now.

1.) Magneto 😆

I just want a badass, classic, definitive Mags & I feel like it hasn't been nailed yet

2.) Toad

In one of his pudgy pre90s depictions. I like the way this one looks..

3.) Avalanche

classic . stocky

4.) Mystique

Of all the characters they cursed with the Kate Bishop mold, she was the one that saddened me most

5.) Deathbird

classic

6.) Apocalypse

Preferably Fall of the Mutants accurate, but would be down for the retro figure in blue colorway as well.

7.) Sebastian Shaw

I need that buff shirtless bastard

8.) Sabretooth

Like so

9.) Sentinel

Big, classic, accurate ones. Yea right, but hey I can dream.

10.) Ahab

One of my top favorite figures as a kid and knew absolutely nothing about him

Let's go! 

1. Armor

2. Ms. Marvel (X-Uniform)

3. Storm (Avengers)

4. Sentinel (Marvel vs. Capcom)

5. Synch

6. Daken (Dark Avengers)

7. Prodigy

8. Magneto (New Mutants)

9. Mondo 

10. Cyclops (Fox)

Heroes:

Banshee (green/yellow)

Husk (Generation X)

Penance/Hollow (Generation X)

Skin (Generation X)

Synch (Generation X)

Psylocke (armored)

Magma

Hepzibah

Raza

Rachel Summers Phoenix

Villains:

Exodus (original look)

Deathbird (classic/Rise and Fall of the Shi'ar Empire, would take Lee though)

Trevor Fitzroy (prefer lime green/blue, would take the armor)

Albert and Elsie Dee (minimally articulated pack-in is fine for her)

Arclight

Scalphunter/Greycrow

Harpoon

Mimic (classic)

Warstar

Oracle