The Official Fwoosh 2025 Top 10 Poll - RESULTS ARE IN!

The results are in!

Many thanks to everybody that voted!

Many, many thanks to my wife for double checking my tabulations!

First off, here are some tabulation clarifications:

-I added lesser totals to higher totals if a character got votes in both the standard Top 10 and the BAF/Deluxe categories, and a few between BAF/Deluxe and HasLab/Made-To-Order. Although I combined them, the final totals did not affect the top tallies at all.

-There were a few characters that got equal number of votes for both standard size and BAF/Deluxe characters. In each instance, I favored BAF/Deluxe because each had large wings (like Deluxe Angel) and made more sense in the BAF/Deluxe category.

-I combined almost all character costumes/appearances into one tally. Such as all Kitty Pryde and Shadowcat votes were combined. Same with multiple costumes for characters like Storm. The vote breakdown is included. Votes that didn't have a specific description or were listed as 'classic' are in the final total but not the vote breakdown description. Some characters were separated by identities, notably evil-turned-good like Erik Josten and Karla Soften.

-MCU, animated, game and comic versions were all counted separately.

-One unfortunate thing: I think the rumor/leak list affected votes.

Please keep in mind that this is how I decided to tally everything. It may not be the best way and I’m sure there may have been a more efficient way to tally and keep all votes completely separate, but this is the best I got.

 

And now - here's the Top 10!

Just want to get in between the preamble and the results 🙂

What if he’s editing the preamble post?!

Posted by: @normdapito

↑

What if he’s editing the preamble post?!

 

Yeah... that occurred to me after I posted.    

 

Context clues will tell people I was commenting mid-edit  😀

 

I can't wait to see the results. 😀

Here's the Top 10 Standard Figures! (Well, 11 due to a tie)

 

23 Votes

Skurge the Executioner (2 votes were BAF/Deluxe) 

 

16 Votes (Tie)

Attuma

 

Rachel Summers (all votes were variations of Excalibur, Phoenix and Hound)

 

15 Votes

Marrina

 

13 Votes

Psylocke (9 votes were Armored/Outback, 2 votes Disassembled, 1 vote 80s, 1 vote "pink gown" which is the early costume with the puffy-ish sleeves)

 

12 Votes

Jack of Hearts

 

11 Votes

Mantis (4 votes specifically said human/flesh tone skin)

 

9 Votes (TIE)

Feral (4 votes were X-Force)

 

Mandarin (2 votes were for the 1960s green/purple suit with the pointy mask, 1 vote bare chest costume, 1 vote green robes (Face Off), 1 vote flesh tone green armor from the 3 3/4 figure)

 

8 Votes (TIE)

Magik (4 votes were classic New Mutants with metal arm, 1 vote larger body, 1 vote post-Limbo gold, 1 vote Darkchylde)

 

Magma (Several votes and pictures indicated the powered up look)

 

Top 5 BAF/Deluxe Figures! (Well, 6 due to a tie)

 

14 Votes

Armor (1 vote standard size, 1 vote Astonishing)

 

7 Votes (TIE)

M'Baku (2 votes standard size)

 

Stegron (2 votes standard size, 1 vote Lizard size)

 

4 Votes (TIE)

Annihilus (2 votes standard size)

 

Box (1 vote specifically Roger Bochs, 1 vote classic red or blue)

 

Volstagg (1 vote standard size)

 

 

TOP 5 HASLAB/MADE-TO-ORDER

 

7 Votes

Fin Fang Foom

 

4 Votes

Atlas (2 votes 90s/Thunderbolts), 1 vote was BAF/Deluxe)

 

Cameron Hodge

 

Mangog (1 vote BAF/Deluxe)

 

3 Votes

Goliath (Eric Josten)

 

 

 

Seems pretty solid.

 

So 6 of the overall top 10 were on my top 10 list, including all of the top 4 and 5 of the top 6.    That would seem to suggest pretty good alignment for me with the wants of this group in general.

 

Also my choices for BAF and HasLab/Made to Order were #2 in each category ... I can live with that.   

But M'baku would be WAY easier for them to make than Armor.   Way easier -  it's just a new head, new loin covering piece, new hands and new feet with the Sasquatch/Wendigo body.  Easy peasy.   

 

And Atlas would be much more productive to make as he could be re-used for other Giant characters going forward where as Foom is a one and done kind of deal.

 

Just throwing that out there Hasbro, in case you're listening  😉 

The rest of the tabulations...

 

 

STANDARD SIZE

 

7 Votes

Anaconda (2 votes BAF)

Deathbird

Gargoyle

Hepzibah (1 vote skunky fresh)

Kitty Pryde (3 votes Astonishing, 2 votes Sprite/1^st appearance, 1 vote Excalibur II, 1 vote Shadowkat assassin)

Swordsman

Valkyrie (1 vote 70s Defenders, 1 vote Brunhilda)

 

6 Votes

Colossus (3 votes Outback of which one vote was BAF/Deluxe, 2 votes Astonishing, 1 vote Jim Lee/90s Gold Team suit)

Exodus

Firebird (1 vote cape included)

Mephisto (1 vote Deluxe with throne)

Synch (2 votes Generation X)

Wizard

 

5 Votes

Air-Walker (1 vote BAF/Deluxe)

Cannonball (3 votes 90s X-Men/Onslaught, 1 vote classic New Mutants, 1 vote Zero Tolerance)

Colleen Wing

Falcon (70s red & white suit)

Gorgon

Jubilee (4 votes Generation X, 1 vote Vampire)

Namorita (all votes variations of classic early NW, green costume, human skin tone)

Skin (Generation X)

Starfox

Storm (2 votes AoA, 1 vote Avengers/From the Ashes, 1 vote Disassembled, 1 vote Outback suit with lightning insignia and long hair

 

4 Votes

Beast (2 votes Perez sculpt, 1 vote Astonishing, 1 vote X-Terminators)

Cardiac

Cypher (2 votes classic New Mutants, 2 votes Krakoa-era suit)

Graviton

Iron Man (3 votes Improvised Armor/Ohta design/Model 74, 1 vote modern Tony Stark, no armor)

Madcap

Moonstone (Masters of Evil)

Swarm

Penance (Generation X)

Pixie

Sidewinder

Thor (2 votes Heroic Age/Coipel, 1 vote silver age, 1 vote Simonson armored)

Triton

Werewolf By Night (1 vote both wolf forms)

Wiccan

Wonder Man (3 votes classic/90s WCA, 1 vote first appearance)

Yellowjacket

 

3 Votes

America Chabez (comic)

Balder

Baron Blood

Blade (2 votes 70s first appearance, 1 vote Nightstalkers)

Blastaar

Bucky (classic Invaders/golden age)

Captain Britain (first appearance/original costume)

Carrion

Crimson Dynamo

Cyclops (1 vote Byrne, 1 vote graduation suit, 1 vote New Mutants/Morrison)

Death Adder

Dr. Druid

Echo (MCU)

Edwin Jarvis

Ghost Rider (Robbie Reyes)

Hogun

Nebula (1 vote Buscema)

Overdrive

Plantman (2 votes cape & mask)

Red Wolf (2 votes bronze age, 1 vote with Lobo)

Silhouette (1 vote first New Warriors look)

Stingray

Talisman (Elizabeth Twoyoungmen)

Trapster

Two-Gun Kid (Matt Hawk silver age)

Vermin

Wolverine (Team X)

 

2 Votes

Adam Warlock (1 vote bronze age Starlin)

Baron Mordo

Battlestar

Boomerang (classic)

Bug

Calypso (classic)

Chitauri (MCU)

Daredevil (1 vote classic, 1 vote Secret Wars)

Diablo

Diamondback

Fandral

Gamora (classic, 1 vote Starlin)

Gladiator (Potter)

Greycrow/Scalphunter (classic Marauders)

Hellion

Human Torch (Jim Hammond – golden age)

Jean Grey (1 vote X-Factor green, 1 vote X-Men Red)

Lilith Drake

Man-Wolf (Stargod)

Mary Jane Watson (first appearance/John Romita)

Mastermind

Meteorite

Mimic

Mole Man

Nightcrawler (90s AoA)

Owl

Pete Wisdom (comic, 1 vote extra head with eye patch – X-Force)

Phantom Rider

Phyla-Vell

Pip the Troll (comic)

Raza Longknife

Revanche (90s)

Rogue (1 vote Savage Land, 1 vote Uncanny Avengers)

Ronin (New Avengers)

Sabretooth (1 vote Captive – Phalanx Covenant, 1 vote Team X)

Sage (1 vote X-Treme X-Men, 1 vote red and black suit

Senyaka (1 vote Acolyte)

Sersi (classic green)

Sunspot (1 vote fully powered up)

Surge

Techno (1 vote first Thunderbolts look)

Typhoid Mary (classic)

Volcana (Secret Wars)

White Tiger (Hector Ayala)

Wasp (1 vote Under Siege, 1 vote black and yellow modern)

Wolfsbane (1 vote Excalibur)

 

1 Vote

Abomination (classic on bigger body)

Absorbing Man (classic)

Abyss (AoA)

Ahab

Albert & Elsie Dee

Amelia Voght (Acolyte)

Americop

Angelica Jones (Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends)

Anole

Arabian Knight (Sinbad look)

Ares (Dark Avengers)

Aunt May

Aunt May (MCU)

Baron Von Strucker (Earth’s Mightiest Heroes)

Basilisk (Basil Elks 80s handbook)

Bishop (AoA)

Black Mamba

Blink (X-Men Days of Futures Past movie)

Bobby Drake (Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends)

Bolt (NW volume 2)

Bullseye (Dark Avengers)

Captain America (MCU First Avenger)

Captain Mar-Vell (Starlin)

Captain Ultra

Cecilia Reyes

Chamber (Generation X uniform with jacket)

Crippler

Cyclops (Fox, Apocalypse end scene)

Daken

Dani Moonstar (with Valkyrie accessories)

Darcy Lewis (MCU)

Daredevil (MCU – She-Hulk)

Deadly Nightshade (classic)

Defensor

Demolition Man

Diamond Lil

Doc Samson

Domino (ToyBiz Greg Capullo blue and purple costume)

Dr. Doom (classic)

Dr. Octopus (white Armani suit with bendy tentacles)

Dr. Strange (Modern – Savage Avengers)

Dracula (70s Gene Colan style)

Drax the Destroyer (Hercules retro buck)

Dust

Echo (New Avengers)

El Aguila

Elven

Emma Frost (Generation X)

Fat Cobra

Frankenstein’s Monster (classic)

Frenzy (post Age of X)

General Ross (Modern)

Genis-Vell (90s legacy)

Ghoul (Jonathan Martin)

Goblin Queen (Inferno)

Goliath (Hank Pym)

Grandmaster

Green Goblin (silver age with bat-wing Goblin Glider)

Guang Bo (MCU)

GW Bridge

Harry Osborn (classic 616)

Harvest (Phalanx Covenant)

Black Mamba, Princess Python)

Havok (AoA)

Hawkeye (Hawkguy) with Pizza Dog

Heimdall

Hercules (70s classic skirt)

High Evolutionary (MCU)

Hydra Soldier (Earth’s Mightiest Heroes)

Iceman (Portacio/Lee)

Iceman (Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends)

Ikari

Invisible Woman (1995 opera gloves suit)

Jimmy Woo

Jolt (first Thunderbolts look)

Julia Carpenter (Sony, Madame Web)

Kaecilius

Karma

Karnak (ANAD)

Karolina Dean

Killraven

Kraven (PS5)

Kurse (MCU)

Kylun

Layla Miller

Leader (90s Hulk cartoon)

Legion (FX Legion tv show)

Living Lightning

Living Mummy (classic)

Loki

Lord Pumpkin

Luna Snow

Mandrill

Mantra I (Eden Blake/Lucanz)

Marvel Boy (first NW look, swappable heads & removable cape)

Master of the World

Maverick (Team X)

Medusa

Moira X

Mondo

Mr. Knight

Ms. Marvel (X-uniform)

Multiple Man (X-Factor)

Nebula (MCU, Endgame)

Night Thrasher

Nightcrawler (Fox, Apocalypse end scene)

Nightmare

Nightwatch (NOT Deathwatch)

Nomad (Jack Monroe)

Peter Parker (Spider-Man and His Amazing Friends)

Polaris (Giant-Size X-Men)

Prime

Prototype (Jimmy Ruiz)

Punisher (trench coat from Epic Heroes wave)

Puppet Master

Quicksilver (AoA)

Rancor

Reaper (MLF)

Red Guardian II (Tania Belinskaya)

Reese (Reavers)

Rick Jones – A-Bomb

Rintrah

Robbie Robertson

Rocket Raccoon (MCU, Endgame)

Rocket Racer

Rogue (Animated series neon green)

Ruby Thursday

Satanna (classic/Vampire Tales)

Scarlet Witch (ANAD)

Scorpion (PS4)

Shang-Chi (with gi top)

Shocker (PS4)

Shotgun (Punisher War Zone costume)

Shroud

Sif

Simon Garth, Zombie (classic)

Slapstick

Spider-Man (Ultimate 6160)

Spider-Slayer

Spot

Spyke (X-Men Evolution)

Stardust

Storm (Fox, Apocalypse end scene)

Tempo (classic, with alternate modern head)

Tempus

Texas Twister

The Maker

Thing (Fantastic Four tank tops, pants and boots)

Troll (Gunna Sijurvald)

Turbo (first NW look)

Uncle Ben Parker

Vanguard

Vector

Vengeance

Viv Vision

War Machine (MCU, Infinity War)

Wasp (Earth’s Mightiest Heroes)

Whiplash (MCU)

Whizzer (golden age/70s)

Wild Thing

X-23 (Deadpool & Wolverine)

Ying Nan (MCU)

Yuki

Zelma Stanton

Zzzax (90s Hulk cartoon)

 

 

 

BAF/DELUXE

3 Votes

Titanium Man (1 vote for Gremlin armor)

 

2 Votes

Aragorn (1 vote included Brightwind, also removable wings)

Bushmaster

Gatecrasher

Holocaust (AoA)

Hulk (Merged Hulk, 1 vote Pantheon-era jumpsuit)

Hulk (Smart Hulk, 1 vote standard size)

Hulkling (1 vote standard size)

Iceman (with ice accessories)

Shuma Gorath

 

1 Vote

Banshee (Phantom Rider’s horse)

Bi-Beast (2008 Hulk video game)

Champion of the Universe

Destroyer (MCU)

In-Betweener

Mondo (Generation X)

NM-E

Onslaught (AoA)

Phoenix firebird in blue

Rhino (Ultimate)

Rockslide

Sasquatch

Varnae, Lord of the Vampires

 

 

HASLAB/MADE-TO-ORDER

2 Votes

Awesome Android

Black Goliath (1 vote BAF/Deluxe size with the yellow collar, chest/abdomen open costume)

Danger Room (1 vote 90s modular, 1 vote diorama including X-Jet cockpit/cabin, War Room)

Devil Dinosaur

FantastiCar/Fantasticar II

Goliath (Clint Barton, 1 vote specifically 15 to 18 inches)

Griffin (1 vote standard size)

Living Monolith

Quinjet (MCU)

Surtur (1 vote Simonson)

 

1 Vote

Hulk (starship)

Krakoa (as a tree)

Phalanx (modular army builder set)

Red Ronin

Satannish

Super-Adaptoid

Supreme Intelligence

Terminus

Watcher (bronze age)

X-Jet

Yellowjacket

 

Thank you, Beamish! Your efforts are appreciated!

The only 2 that I had on my personal list that seemed to get any broad level of support were Armor and Magma so I hope that we see them both relatively soon!

I also laughed out loud when I saw that I was absolutely the ONLY one who voted for my personal #1 want: Rockslide. I guess I know what the odds are of ever seeing him in figure form are now. Ha! I'd better make a custom if I want one. It appears that I was also the only sole vote for each of Krakoa, Rick Jones and Robbie Robertson. It is what it is. 😏 

Is the one vote for Onslaught (AOA) meant to be Holocaust, as I don't remember an Onslaught character in AOA?  So then AOA Holocaust would have 3 votes?

So, I would totally buy a Rockslide figure and would love to have him.   

 

But he doesn't even make my current top 10 of X-character wants though.    That's the thing, there are so many figures I want and need in Legends it gets crowded in a hurry and so tons of very worthy characters get squeezed surprisingly far down the list.

Thanks for doing this Beamish!

I got 4 in the top ten and 2 for the BAF.  So I guess there's some hope that the guys at Hasbro might knock a few off my list.

I gotta say that it's a very solid top ten.  I would purchase every single one of them if they were made.

I would be more selective when it comes to the BAF and HasLab choices here 😉

Thank you Beamish! Also thank you to people who vote, hopefully the Hasbro team still reads this (and I bet they do). None of my choices made the top 10 but that's okay. Armor would have been my second choice for a BAF after Mondo for sure. In general, though, I'm in for almost all X-men or related characters unless they are redos on characters that have already been made in outfits I have no interest in.

It's really great to see some new blood making their way into the Top 10 since a few key characters finally got made in the last year or two! Excited to see how highly Attuma and Jack of Hearts ranked especially.

Thanks so much for doing all the hard work, Beamish! To the Fwoosh team - any chance the results could be published on the front page?

@jtmarsh  No clue. I just transferred it as initially written to my spreadsheet.